How to Get More Google Reviews (And Why They Affect Your Ranking, Not Just Your Reputation)

November 10, 2026

If I asked you why Google reviews matter, you would probably say something about reputation. About trust. About what people think when they see three stars versus five.

You would be right. But you would only be half right.

Google reviews are also one of the signals Google uses to decide which local businesses show up in search results and which ones get buried. The number of reviews you have, how recent they are, how often new ones come in, and how you respond to them all play a role in where you land when someone searches for a business like yours.

Most local business owners I talk to have no idea this is happening. They think reviews are a customer service thing. Something that happens after the fact. And because they think of it that way, they never build a process around it. They just hope reviews show up on their own.

Hope is not a strategy. And when it comes to reviews, it is leaving both your reputation and your search visibility on the table.

What Google Actually Looks At

Google has said publicly that review signals are a factor in local search rankings. The specifics include the number of reviews, the average rating, and how recently the reviews were posted.

But here is what matters in practice: it is not just about having a lot of reviews. It is about having a steady flow of recent reviews.

Think of it like fishing. You do not haul in a big catch one weekend and then stop going out for six months. If you want consistent results, you go out consistently. You put your line in the water regularly. Reviews work the same way. A business that got 40 reviews in 2021 and nothing since is sending a very different signal than a business that picks up three or four reviews every month.

Google notices the difference. And so do your potential customers.

The Pattern I See Over and Over in Southeastern Connecticut

I look at Google Business Profiles for local businesses every week. It is part of what I do for my clients, and the pattern is almost always the same.

One business has 70 or 80 recent reviews. Steady stream. Owner or office manager responds to most of them. The profile is filled out, photos are current, and the business shows up in the Map Pack when someone searches for that service in their area.

The other a few miles away has 12 reviews, most of them from 2021 or 2022. No responses from the owner. Half the profile fields are empty. And they are wondering why the phone is not ringing.

I have seen this pattern with dental practices, roofing contractors, law firms, and chimney sweeps across southeastern Connecticut. The businesses that are actively collecting reviews are outranking the ones that are not. It is not the only factor, but it is one of the most visible ones, and it is one of the easiest to actually do something about.

Why Dental Practices and Healthcare Providers Have a Built-In Advantage

If you run a dental practice or any kind of healthcare business, you already have something most other businesses do not: a built-in moment when patients expect to be asked for feedback.

Patients are used to filling out forms. They are used to follow-up communications. Asking for a review after an appointment fits naturally into a workflow that already exists. The gap between the practices that do this consistently and the ones that do not is enormous.

I have worked with dental practices where one office in Groton had 80 or 90 recent Google reviews, and a competing practice nearby had a handful from years ago. The one with the steady review flow was showing up at the top of the Map Pack. The other practice had a perfectly good dentist doing great work, but almost nobody was finding them online.

That is not a reputation problem. That is a visibility problem. And it started because nobody in the office ever built the review ask into their process.

Contractors have a similar opportunity, even if it takes a different form. When you finish a roofing job or a plumbing repair and the homeowner is standing there shaking your hand and telling you what a great job you did, that is the moment. If you wait three days to send a follow-up email, you have already lost most of the momentum.

How to Build a Review Process That Actually Works

Getting reviews is not about running a campaign. It is about building a simple habit into how your business operates. Here is what I tell my clients.

Ask Everyone, Not Just the Happy Ones

This is important, and it is also what Google requires. You cannot cherry-pick who you ask. Do not send your happiest customers to Google and route everyone else somewhere different. Google calls this “selective solicitation,” and it is a violation of their review policy. The good news is that if you are doing good work, asking everyone will still produce a strong review profile. Most satisfied customers are happy to leave a quick review when you make it easy.

Make It Easy

Your Google Business Profile has a direct review link you can share. Use it. Put it in a follow-up email. Print it on a card with a QR code. Text it after an appointment. The fewer steps between “will you leave us a review?” and the actual review form, the more reviews you will get.

Ask at the Right Moment

The best time to ask is right after you have delivered a good experience. For a dental practice, that is at checkout or in a same-day follow-up message. For a contractor, it is when the job is done and the customer is satisfied. For a law firm, it is when the case wraps up and the client is relieved. Do not wait a week. The impulse to leave a review fades fast.

Keep It Consistent

Three or four reviews a month, every month, is better than 20 in January and zero for the rest of the year. Google values recency, and so do the people reading your reviews. A steady drip tells Google that this is an active, legitimate business. A burst followed by silence looks unnatural.

Respond to Every Review

Good reviews, bad reviews, mediocre reviews. Respond to all of them. A short, genuine response shows potential customers that a real person is paying attention. It shows Google the same thing. You do not need to write a novel. “Thank you, we appreciate you taking the time” is fine for a positive review. For a negative one, be professional, acknowledge their experience, and offer to make it right offline.

What Not to Do

Google has gotten more specific in recent years about what businesses can and cannot do when it comes to review solicitation. Here is the short version of what to avoid.

Do not offer discounts, gift cards, or any incentive in exchange for a review. Do not ask customers to say specific things or use specific words. Do not set internal quotas or targets for how many reviews your staff needs to collect per week. Do not have customers leave reviews from a tablet in your office while standing at the front desk.

All of these can result in reviews being removed, and in serious cases, restrictions on your entire Google Business Profile.

The right approach is simple. Ask every customer for honest feedback, give them the link, and let them write the review on their own time, in their own words, on their own device. That is what Google wants to see, and it is what builds a review profile that actually holds up over time.

Reviews Are Not Separate from Your SEO. They Are Part of It.

This is the point I want to drive home. If you are investing in SEO for your business, if you are working on your website, optimizing your Google Business Profile, and building citations, but you are ignoring reviews, you are leaving a piece of the puzzle on the table.

Reviews are not a separate project. They are part of the same system. A strong Google Business Profile with consistent reviews, a well-optimized website, and accurate business listings across the web all work together. When I set up a new client, one of the first conversations we have is about their review process, because it affects everything else we are going to do.

I have been doing local SEO for more than 15 years, and I can tell you that the businesses that treat reviews as part of their marketing, not just something that happens to them, consistently outperform the ones that do not. It is not complicated. But it does take a system and the discipline to stick with it.

Frequently Asked Questions About Google Reviews and Local SEO

How many Google reviews do I need to show up in local search results?

There is no magic number. What matters more than total count is consistency and recency. A business with 30 reviews that are spread steadily over the past year will typically perform better in local search than one with 50 reviews that all came in two years ago. Focus on building a steady flow rather than chasing a specific number.

Can I ask my customers to leave Google reviews?

Yes. Google explicitly allows businesses to ask customers for reviews. The key rules are that you have to ask everyone equally, not just the customers you think will leave positive reviews. You cannot offer incentives, suggest specific wording, or pressure anyone. Just make it easy, provide the direct link, and let them write the review in their own words.

Do Google reviews actually affect where my business shows up in search?

Yes. Google has stated that review signals, including the number of reviews, average rating, and recency, are factors in local search ranking. Reviews are not the only factor, but they are one of the most actionable ones. In most cases, a business with a strong, recent review profile will have an advantage over a competitor with few or outdated reviews.

Should I respond to negative Google reviews?

Absolutely. A professional, calm response to a negative review shows potential customers that you take feedback seriously. Do not argue or get defensive. Acknowledge their experience, apologize if appropriate, and offer to resolve it offline. How you respond to criticism tells people as much about your business as the review itself.

How often should I be getting new Google reviews?

A few reviews per month is a healthy pace for most local businesses. The goal is consistency, not volume. A dental practice that picks up three or four reviews a month is in great shape. A contractor who gets one or two after each completed job is building something valuable over time. The worst thing you can do is collect a bunch of reviews all at once and then stop asking.

Let Me Take a Look at Your Review Profile

Want to know where your reviews stand and what they might be doing for your search visibility? I will pull up your Google Business Profile, look at your review count and recency, compare you to your local competitors, and tell you exactly what I see.

No pressure, no pitch. Just an honest look at where you are and what you could be doing better.

Give me a call at 860-317-2347 or send me an email at robert@letitbe-local.com. I am right here in New London, and I have been helping local businesses with this for more than 15 years.

Get in touch today!

Contact Us
First Name
Last Name

Ready to Get Started?

We would love to help you accelerate your business. Get in touch today to learn more about how we can help you achieve your online objectives.
LET'S GO!
ABOUT
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram